Kenzie Biggins is the founder and CEO of Worxbee, a leading provider of Virtual Executive Assistant (VEA) services.
Hiring great talent is what HR leaders do best. You have processes, assessments and best practices down to a science. But there’s one role—one deceptively simple role—that can quietly trip up even the most experienced teams: the executive assistant.
No one seems to openly talk about it, but ask around behind closed doors and you’ll likely hear the same thing: Hiring great executive assistants (EAs) is harder than many like to admit. As the founder of a company that provides virtual EA support, I’ve seen that the usual methods don’t always work. Job descriptions often miss the mark, and, despite best efforts, the fit sometimes feels off. Why is that?
Why Executive Assistants Are Uniquely Challenging To Hire
Most roles come with clear boxes to check—skills, qualifications, experience. But EAs defy a standard checklist. They’re not only responsible for tasks; they are a direct extension of the leader they support.
A great EA needs to seamlessly align with their executive’s personality and work style. It’s not enough to manage a calendar or process expenses—they must anticipate needs, communicate with emotional intelligence and adapt in real time. The wrong fit can cause friction. The right one can transform an executive’s effectiveness.
The challenge? These qualities don’t show up neatly on a resume or job description. Hiring an EA requires a nuanced approach that balances technical skill, high emotional intelligence, servant leadership and—most importantly—chemistry.
What Often Goes Wrong
One of the biggest hiring pitfalls is assuming all EAs are the same. In reality, the EA title has become inflated. Many administrative professionals hold the title without having the deep skills or experience required to truly excel in the role.
I’ve found HR teams often default to job description-based hiring, focusing primarily on hard skills and previous titles. But unlike other positions, a job description can’t capture the intangible qualities that make an EA successful: adaptability, anticipation, high emotional intelligence and seamless alignment with the executive’s work style.
Another common misstep? Underestimating the role itself. It’s easy to assume administrative tasks are straightforward and anyone organized can handle them. But that mindset can lead to underqualified hires who lack the ability to manage the complexity and pace of executive-level demands.
Three Key Considerations When Hiring EA Talent
If hiring an EA feels more difficult than filling other roles, it’s because it is. Traditional hiring methods overlook the unique dynamics of the EA position. To improve your success rate, here are three critical factors to prioritize:
1. Emotional Intelligence And Servant Leadership
The best EAs anticipate needs before they’re spoken, adapt seamlessly to shifting priorities and possess a strong servant leadership mindset. Look for candidates who naturally think one step ahead and thrive in a support-driven role. To assess this in the interview stage, ask candidates to describe a time they de-escalated a tense situation or supported a frustrated executive. Listen for self-awareness, empathy and adaptability.
2. Systems And Process Orientation
A great EA is not just reactive—they’re proactive. Beyond handling tasks, they excel at mapping workflows, identifying gaps and implementing systems that keep everything running smoothly. This ability to create order out of complexity is what separates average EAs from exceptional ones. I recommend asking a potential EA how they’ve created or improved a workflow in the past. Strong EAs will explain how they identified pain points and implemented tools or routines to drive efficiency.
3. Personality And Work Style Fit
Even the most skilled EA won’t thrive without alignment with the executive they support. Work style preferences, communication habits and personality traits all play a role in determining whether the partnership succeeds. I’ve seen firsthand, through developing my own pairing methodologies and assessment processes, how critical this alignment is. Prioritize fit as highly as qualifications.
Don’t underestimate the value of behavioral assessments and targeted questions during interviews, such as, “What type of leadership style brings out your best work?” or, “How do you adapt when your executive’s communication style differs from your own?” These small shifts in your process can lead to dramatically better matches.
How to Source EA Talent Differently
The good news? You don’t have to navigate this hiring challenge alone. There are smarter ways to approach EA hiring that go beyond the standard methods:
Deepen internal understanding.
Start by revisiting how your organization defines the EA role. Move past generic job descriptions and get clear on what true EA excellence looks like—balancing technical ability with emotional intelligence, adaptability, and personality fit. Consider incorporating assessments to help evaluate candidates’ emotional intelligence and work style traits. I’ve consistently seen a direct correlation between this approach and long-term, successful EA partnerships.
Consider consulting EA experts.
You don’t have to be an EA hiring expert to succeed—you just need to know where to turn. As someone who nerds out over all things EA-related, I can confidently say: Most of us in the space welcome a conversation with HR leaders who want guidance. After all, the better we align great EA talent with the right executives, the stronger our entire industry becomes. Some companies might also find it beneficial to call in EA-specific recruiters and service providers to help navigate the nuances and complexities of hiring for this role.
Rethinking Your Approach To EA Hiring
Hiring EAs is unlike filling any other role—and it’s time we acknowledged that. When the right EA is in place, the ripple effect touches every part of an executive’s effectiveness—and the organization’s success.
Take a moment to review how you’re currently sourcing, assessing and hiring EA talent. Are you accounting for personality fit, leadership style alignment and emotional intelligence? Or are you relying too heavily on job descriptions and hard skills? A thoughtful audit now could unlock stronger executive support down the road.
Forbes Business Council is the foremost growth and networking organization for business owners and leaders. Do I qualify?
